Iphone doesn’t rattle even remotely like this. I’ve seen a footage on Vivo 200U with much softer rattling.
15U seem to over-rattle, especially when you record some action video. Imagine you want to record a video on a yacht, outland in car, or just jogging, you fix the phone, and video is constantly being interrupted by the rattle sounds that over-ride your voice or surroundings
This just doesn’t seem normal, no, I can tolerate, understand rattling sound when phone is offline, I can less tolerate it when it’s online I think it should be hard-locked when camera is not used.
But the rattle sound IN THE VIDEO ITSELF I think it’s just the worst design possible or defect. I understand the phone is mostly for photography but to neglect the phone’s ability to record videos for this price in “Ultra” is just lazy in my eyes.
I heard from some people probably shills that they don’t have rattle when camera is activated.
Can you confirm that the rattle video is present in your videos if you mildly shake your phone especially horizontally not vertically?
I don’t know buddy about you but my phone works fine. If the camera is used, it does not rattle.
Can you make a video with it, and shake it mildly like I asked? If you describe true then most users who report rattle in video are recieinvg defected phones
Why are people downvoting the comment and upvoting the guy without any proof that it does not rattle because multiple people have been uploading their footages with insane rattling heard in the footage lol.
[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zw4Ez-qFWfs](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zw4Ez-qFWfs)
\^\^\^
This is not normal video
Im waiting for the proof that your videos are different lol
That’d just prove that part of phones are made with defected camera
I’m not gonna say it doesn’t happen, but the thing is that very few are going to be shaking the phone around. My videos for example are just stationary with zooming or panning so I’ve never considered any rattle to be a problem
I have the same problem with my X15U and another one with background noise when 60 fps recording.
Same here with less shaking but you can hear rattle 🙁https://drive.proton.me/urls/3PRB0M0Z94#wy4V8sY5MGM_)
Same for me, you can hear it in my video : [rattle sound](https://drive.proton.me/urls/3PRB0M0Z94#wy4V8sY5MGM_)
Yes, your movement is a little slower than on the video. If you could try more / max out the shake like you’re on a dirtbike or smth XD
I’d be greatful.
This is confusing, because some poeple like that guy say there is no sound at all while some confirm with videos that rattle is present.
I just want to understand, if there is a difference in user expirience – we all get the same, or someone lucky get better.
well lucky your lifestyle, I have sometimes active lifestyle which indeed will involve phone be shaking, and I don’t want my video history to be just a rattlesnake noise overriding the sound i want to capture instead.
Why would you shake you phone so much as in your video, lol. Makes zero sense to me as no action scene involves such shaking of phone.
I have taken a video running with my phone and sudden movement to capture a moving shot, no sound capture in mic.
It is my second x15u, the first has 5g defect after 7 days so it was replaced but i think that the first unit hasn’t any rattle or less when moving. But i haven’t tried in video with it. For me, it is a defect in video, no sound should be present. And can you please try to record a video for my noise issue ?
This is a video I shot recently you can hear the audio – https://www.instagram.com/reel/DJPHHcNpEke/?igsh=MzRlODBiNWFlZA==
Dirtbiking, yachting, jogging, clubbing, any situation, driving a car in wilderness, why are you whitewashing this? Even if I shake it less, it is still audible with at least 50% volume as all other sounds on the video. And it’s interfering.
What’s the point of your lie “my works perrfectly fine” when you now try to find excuse that I shake it wrong?
imagine shilling so much for a top phone with such lazy bad design in ois.
Not right now, mine was approved for return just now, lol
I too don’t think that it’s normal for a video. I think it’s lazy design because OIS on other camera moduls doesn’t work when you make video, so it’s not the main camera issue but the issue of powered off magnets from other cameras. I think.
Very lazy and sad, it completely ruins the action video record for me
Yes i think so. Why i have sold my x14u ? I don’t remember if it was the case for my previous x14u ? Maybe Xiaomi can activate magnet for all lens in video?
Buddy I have jogged with the phone and taken a video. If the rattle sound is not an issue there then in most scenarios it won’t be an issue.
So it’s not whitewashing but being concerned with practical scenarios of phone usage and not going after nit-picking of issues.
Mhm mhm, so can you send a video with a mild to strong shake to prove it?
I’ve tried to move phone for a long time, simulating for some natural footages, and it rattles every time.
The way it works is that whichever camera is active, its OIS is also active therefore its rattle is reduced. In your video only one camera was active (main) but the 2 other optically stabilized ones were not (telephotos). This is why you still hear their rattle.
For example, if you record a video with the ultra wide lens and shake your phone, the rattle is much louder because the ultra wide is the only rear lens without OIS. and all the other lenses will be inactive therefore they will rattle.
I did exactly that and heard rattle, so your device is not defective. It’s just the way OIS works.
I think the above average loudness is just a byproduct of how massive the sensors in this phone are, and having the sensors “held” when not in use would just consume more power.
Look up how OIS work, evem on a mirrorless camera there are rattle with the IS. Of course the iPhone doesn’t do the same level of noise doe to the small sensors, your phone can do 800mbs log raw video do to the big sensor, try that on the iPhone. Your rant does not make any sense when you don’t understand how it works. If you don’t like it, leave it and go for that iPhone . Any other ultra with camera modules like this will do exactly the same. Don’t call it flaw out bad design, instead educate your self on the matter.
I don’t know if your arrogance worse than shilling for this.
The fact they refunded people for defects with the rattle + Samsung did the warranty replacements just acknowledge that this is more a problem rather than a normal state.
\+ people always say it disappears with camera app on, it is not true, and the fact you can hear it on video and it CAN be WORSE than on other xiaomi-s is just adding to the issue of quality.
Go educate yourself, mister arrogant shill
The same arrogance that you show with all you unfounded reasoning, the difference is that you’re wrong about it. Returns on the rattling are accept because most of the time the worker does not care or is better than hear someone go bla bla bla about it. This is a phone, it takes awesome photos and videos, is not a action camera, is not meant for that use. The gopro does not have OIS for a reason. Filmmakers use rigs on there cameras with IBIS and IS for a reason. Is normal that if you’re using the main camera for video the others sensor will not have OIS actived and so you will hear a rattle, you can’t have all ois always active, it will consume a lot of battery.
How puny and pathetic you are for downvoting me just for asking lol, can you leave me alone please if you don’t like me so much?
I’ve asked for material proof (videos) because some people say rattle stops whatsoever, some say it persists, there are cases of defects, that are followed by refunds, why refund if phone is ok?
On samsung there are actually cases of warranty camera repair with rattling decreases fully or to neglible amounts
Can you actually look on different situation people are in and stfu with your “by the book”? I know what is OIS by the book and how it works, unless you can contribute to the post, your opinion is not valued.
EVEN IF people JUST want to complain they have 100% right for it,
This phone doesn’t cost cheap, and inability to perform a recording of videos without rattling present is a SERIOUS issue for 2025 tech
Idk, I have to be very violent to get that OIS noise to get noticeable, honestly nothing I’ve observed in real life scenarios as of yet.
Are you filming while jogging and swinging the phone in your hand? In casual use I’ve not noticed OIS rattle to be an issue.
I could not care less about personal attacks when you don’t have any better to say. You made a post showing that you don’t know how the phone camera works, how OIS work or that this phone is the right tool for action video recording.
“This just doesn’t seem normal, no, I can tolerate, understand rattling sound when phone is offline, I can less tolerate it when it’s online I think it should be hard-locked when camera is not used.
But the rattle sound IN THE VIDEO ITSELF I think it’s just the worst design possible or defect. I understand the phone is mostly for photography but to neglect the phone’s ability to record videos for this price in “Ultra” is just lazy in my eyes.”
You say this is a bad lazy design, and yet every camera phone have this design, obviously everyone else is wrong. Other people tried to explained to you. You came here just for internet points. Have a good day sir.
Yes, I’ve got a flat foot lol so when i jog my phone can be jiggling and rattle is on the video and it is annoying. The other situation it might be is in the car / certainly dirtbike on a bumpy wild road, anyway almost all sports activity is cursed with rattle and I find it not nice,
What you’re hearing is the inactive OIS from the other lenses which aren’t active. Due the these sensors being much bigger than the likes of the iPhone, they are heavier and unfortunate rattle more than the average phone. Unsure how they’d combat this without activating all lenses OIS when recording
I reckoned a while ago, is there any override solution for this from 14 ultra?
I just went through every single setting and unfortunately there’s no way to control the image stabilisation at all. It’s all automated
Unfortunately. I don’t mind battery drain tbh over solved rattle on video problem.
But well… It is what it is then.
Sorry but xiaomi cannot defy physics. If an iPhone had the same sensors as the xiaomj no doubt they would shake and ruin videos as well
What do you mean by defying physics? Do you really wanna say that rattling video because of sensor is the peak of human technology? Bro, we produce processors in nanometers, and you say they can’t make phone soundless
Yes I am in fact saying that. Take any phone with an ois unit as large as the hp9 sensor’s and you’ll have the same problem.
Saying that we hit the limit on technology is the dumbest thing to say at all.
20 years ago we couldn’t imagine how it’d be right now. You’re saying we cannot do anything with OIS rattle while cameras are actually active XD
Dumb thing to say my friend